- George Ray 1876 - 1921
- Adam Darr 1921 - 1926
- Orland Stiffler 1926
- Jerry Hammond 1927
- George Ruby 1927 - 1929
- Charles Rentfrow 1930 - 1937
- Madison McPherson 1937 - 1940
- Ocal Craft 1940 - 1944
- Bert Cripe 1944 - 1948
- C.T. Kline 1949 - 1952
- James Gilbert 1952 - 1956
- Max Miller 1956
- Don Enyeart 1956 - 1964
- Dan Granger 1965 - 1968
- Orville Vander Ryden 1968 - 1973
- Dale Sparklin 1973 - 1975
- Ron Robinson 1975 - 1978
- Louis Mediano 1979
- Robert Houser 1979 - 1982
- William Selvey 1983
- Warren Swartz 1983 - 1985
- Robert Ziller 1985 - 1995
- William Endler 1996 - 2000
- Thomas Perzanowski 2000 - 2005
- Anthony Ciriello 2005 - 2015
- James M. Layne 2015 - Current